Well, how critical is "too critical"? Or is there even such a thing? We all have our different opinions, and it would be silly to deride people just because something about Dwarf disappoints them. By the same token though, I have noticed an element here that seem to actually take relish in being critical of Dwarf, which does lead me to question how much of a fan they are. No true fan WANTS to be critical of Dwarf, true fans show sadness rather than relish when putting the show down. Also, though I myself have been a bit critical of all Dwarf to some extent post-series VI, I always offer constructive criticsm, and I think it's that key thing which seperates the genuine Dwarfers from the casual ones. We don't just criticise, we offer ideas and insight into how the flaws could be improved or got rid of, rather than just pointing out the flaws themselves.